This is the essay version of my video "From Is to Ought: Foundations of an Objective Morality." Watch it above, or read it here.
Can you get an ought from an is? Philosophers have been stuck on that question ever since David Hume pointed out the gap. Here I'm going to offer one axiom as a proposed bridge across that gap. It's not a magic trick, and it's not the end of the debate. It's a bridge put on the table for you to test.
What I'm proposing is an objective framework with a minimal set of non-negotiable rules. Objective, not relative. Minimal, so almost everything else is left to you.
Why philosophy comes first
For those of you who don't know me, my name is Geoffrey, and I'm a digital renaissance man, which I define as someone who refuses to get good at only one thing and wants to be seriously good at many different things. Philosophy is one of those things, and it comes first, because everything else I do rests on it. How you decide what is worth doing is the foundation under it all.
This is for independent-minded people who would rather think a thing through than be handed a conclusion. You don't have to agree with me. I just ask that you follow the argument to the end.
The mission, plainly: we are doing the hard meta-ethical heavy lifting in an effort to have people stop talking past each other and generally elevate the level of conversation.
I wrote a philosophy blog from 2011 to 2016. My views have changed since then, and in a later series I'll go back through it and review it. For now, here's the plan: first the problem Hume raised, then one serious attempt to solve it from Sam Harris, then my axiom, the rules that follow from it, and finally the hardest cases the framework faces.
Hume's is-ought problem
David Hume noticed that people move from statements about how the world is to statements about how we ought to act, and they do it without explaining that jump. Facts describe. They tell you what exists. An ought tells you what to do, and no pile of descriptions seems to hand you that by itself.
Take a simple case. The fact that a knife is sharp tells you it cuts well. It doesn't tell you whether to cut bread or a person.
That gap is where most secular ethics stalls. You can describe human nature, human preferences, and human societies in perfect detail, and someone can still ask: so what? Why should I? So people often slip in an ought without saying so. They start with facts, then reach for words like should and fair, and nobody notices the step.
Religious ethics has an answer to that: the ought comes from God, from his nature or his command. That is a real answer, and I want to be fair about it. But if you don't accept the premise, it's an answer you can't use. There's also an argument worth raising here: whether God or evolution built in our sense of good and bad, we still have to define good rationally, and we still have to be able to step back from an impulse when it works against us. I offer that as an argument, not as a knockdown.
So the question stands. Is there a way to get an ought that doesn't depend on God and doesn't pretend the gap isn't there?
Sam Harris and The Moral Landscape
A lot of credit has to go to Sam Harris for putting me on this journey with his book The Moral Landscape, published in 2010. In it, Harris tries to cross the is-ought gap with science. Here is his view at its strongest: morality is about the well-being of conscious creatures, a landscape of flourishing peaks and suffering valleys. He compares well-being to physical health, which is hard to define precisely yet is still the object of real science.
Here's my problem: a spectrum is not a standard. Harris gives a direction, more flourishing and less suffering, but no fixed standard. Flourishing measured how? And why does that even count?
Picture someone who wakes up, gets high, pleasures themselves, goes back to sleep, wakes up in the afternoon sad, and takes a prescription to feel better. On a scale of how they feel, that day might score high. But is it flourishing? Only a standard can tell you, because maybe it feels good in the moment but only leads to loneliness and emptiness over the long run. By my standard, which I'll define shortly, I would say no.
But because I prioritize freedom and self-determination, we give people the room to make their own mistakes and their own choices. Judging and forcing are two different things. As long as there's no aggression against anyone else, that person's happiness comes down to none of my business.
And Harris's own health analogy answers the problem. Health has a standard: the life of the organism. That points to my alternative.
A note on animals
Life is the standard of value. Each human has infinite value, and human flourishing comes first. Animals come second, but all else being equal, their flourishing should still be maximized. So factory farming still falls under the category of immoral.
However, a cow's flourishing never happens if the cow is never born. Domestication was, figuratively speaking, the survival strategy these animals chose. If nobody eats them, they go extinct, because there's no place for them in the modern world. One steer gives about as much meat as 180 chickens: one life instead of 180. And a cow, with its higher order of consciousness, potentially holds more conscious flourishing than many chickens. So if you replace all the cows with chickens, or both with lab-grown meat, you lose all of that flourishing potential.
The axiom: life is the standard of value
So here is the axiom. Life is the standard of value.
A standard of value is what you measure other things against. When I say life is the standard, I mean we judge actions, rules, and institutions by whether they serve human life.
I did not invent that idea. Ayn Rand's Objectivist ethics held that life is the standard of value, and that every person is an end in himself, not a means to the ends of others. I'm building on that, and here's how I put it in my own terms, not hers.
Each human life has infinite objective value. Infinite value means lives don't add up. Infinity plus infinity is still infinity. Two lives are not worth more than one, and five aren't worth more than two. So you can't trade one person for several, and the utilitarian sum breaks.
Notice what this changes. A utilitarian asks how many people benefit and then adds them up. If every life is already infinite, there's nothing to add, and the arithmetic stops working.
I want to be honest about what this is. It's my axiom. It's my proposed bridge across Hume's gap, and my answer to the question I opened with. I'm offering it for scrutiny, not claiming it's a proof that ends the debate.
And I'll say again what kind of thing this is: an objective framework with a minimal set of non-negotiable rules. The axiom is fixed, and the rules that follow from it are fixed. Everything else is built on top.
The subjective layer
That is not to say you must feel the same about everyone. People don't, and the framework doesn't ask you to. There is a subjective layer, and it is permitted.
You can value people more because they're close to you, because they're familiar, because they think the way you do, or because they share your genes: proximity, familiarity, agreement in thought, genetics. Valuing your own family more than strangers is moral. It is permitted. I'd rather the framework be honest about real people, and real people do feel closer to some than to others.
But this layer sits on top of the rules. It never replaces them, and it is never a mandate over anyone else. Your preferences don't oblige me, and mine don't oblige you.
The line to hold onto is this: preference tells you whom to favor with your time, your help, and your loyalty. It never tells you whom you may harm.
Think of it as concentric circles. Closest to you are the people you love most, then outward to friends, to neighbors, and to strangers. Your valuation can shrink as the circles widen. The rules reach every circle equally.
The ought and the ought-nots
So what are the rules?
Start with the ought. The ought is your freedom to act and decide for yourself in order to protect and further your own life. That's the positive side. Your life is yours to protect and to further, and your choices are yours to make.
Then the ought-nots. You may not impinge on other people's lives, their property, or their freedom. Picture it as a fence around each person. Inside your fence, you decide. Cross someone else's fence and you've broken the rule.
Notice that the ought is about you, and the ought-nots are about everyone else. One says what you're free to do; the other says where that freedom stops. These rules are small on purpose. A minimal set is easier to defend, and easier for people with very different beliefs to live under together.
Fixed rules, open facts
This is where I want to draw a line between two things: fixed rules and open facts.
The axiom and the rules are fixed. They are not up for a vote. Openness, a big tent, applies only to genuinely open empirical questions, questions of fact that the evidence hasn't settled. On those, people of different worldviews can disagree and still share the same framework. The goal is to agree on how we argue, even where we don't yet agree on the answer.
The hard cases: aggressors forfeit
Now the fun part: the hard cases. If every human life has infinite value, what happens when two lives collide? You can't rank infinities. You can't say one is bigger. So the framework needs a conflict rule, and here it is: aggressors forfeit. Self-defense is the conflict rule.
This is where a lot of moral systems get tested. A system that works only when nobody's interests collide isn't much of a system. Notice that this rule doesn't rank lives. It doesn't say one life counts more. It says that who aggressed matters. That's the rule. Simple. Clean.
The trolley problem
Now consider the trolley problem. A runaway trolley heads for five people, and a lever would send it toward one. It's a tragedy with no aggressor. The ought-nots govern aggression, harming each other on purpose. In the trolley case, neither choice breaks a fixed rule, so both are permitted. This is where the fixed rules stop and the personal layer takes over: conscience, kin, and what you can live with.
In my mind, there's no right answer to the trolley problem. Call it a cop-out, but under this framework either choice could be considered right, and it comes down to the person making the decision having to live with themselves. That's the strength of the framework. This is where we can get into an auditorium and hold a debate while all agreeing on the underlying foundation.
Personally, I couldn't live with myself if I didn't pull that lever, all else being equal. That's my opinion. It's not a rule, and if you wouldn't pull it, you're not wrong. Most people, when asked, say they'd pull it too, but not everybody does, and plenty of people would feel more responsible for the one they killed than for the five they saved. If you know the people on one side of the tracks, the decision gets a lot easier. And what about the scenario where the trolley is headed at one person, but it's your child? Is anyone really going to call that mother evil for saving her child?
I also think we need to leave room for the fact that it's ultimately a split-second decision, so it isn't being made with one's highest cognitive faculties. So while the trolley problem is an interesting thought experiment, it's such an edge case that it doesn't fully test someone's moral reasoning. At the end of the day, we can all empathize with whoever has to pull that lever.
The lifeboat
Now picture a different case: a lifeboat with one too many people in it. First, you have to ask for a volunteer, and if someone gives up their place, we celebrate that as heroism.
Beyond that, the non-aggression principle says you can't push someone out except in self-defense. Not from a boat that's just crowded or short on supplies. But if it's truly sinking and everyone will drown, I'd call pushing someone out self-defense.
Why? Because life is the standard of value. The non-aggression rule comes from life, and it's there to serve life, so it never outranks it. That's why everyone dying is the worst possible outcome: by that standard, it's a total failure. It doesn't matter how many times you add zero; it never makes infinity.
That's my view. It's not chiseled in stone. Debate me.
In either case, none of this is relativism. The rules stay fixed. There are good arguments on both sides, and we can argue within a fixed framework we agree on.
The whole framework in a breath
If you're a Christian, you may recognize the infinite worth of a person from your own study of the Bible. If you're an atheist, you need no God premise at all. The axiom stands on its own.
Here's the whole thing in a breath:
- Life is the standard of value.
- Each human life has infinite objective value, so lives don't add up.
- You're free to act for your own life.
- You may not impinge on another's life, property, or freedom.
- Aggressors forfeit.
An objective framework with a minimal set of non-negotiable rules. One axiom, a few rules, and wide room for the rest of your life.
You don't have to agree with me. If you disagree, tell me exactly where the argument breaks down. I'd like to hear it, and thanks for thinking this through with me.